Friday, November 5, 2010

Heaven in My Foot: The Tuskegee Mentality: Condemning Antiretrovira

 
 
Researchers are obliged to gather the most objective, accurate scientific knowledge they can while doing, so far as is humanly possible, no harm: clinicians are obliged to do all the good they can for the people in their care, period.  In the clinic, only the individual patient's well-being, not the advancement of science, may be consulted.  The patient has a right to demand, and the doctor a duty to provide, any treatment that in their joint judgement may improve the patient's overall condition.  Far from being obligatory, it is forbidden for a doctor to consider the advancement of science in deciding whether to withhold any reasonable therapy from a patient who wants it.  The idea that patients must—or even may—be denied treatment in order to advance science is nothing short of a Tuskegee mentality.
 
* * *
Which is why I was so outraged that doctors repeatedly refused me sleeping pills (known to be safe) and pain pills (known to be safe) for my demonstrated sleep and pain issues, insisting I could only have anti-depressants (known to be useless for CFS).
 
I wasn't asking for anything risky, I wasn't asking for anything the CFS experts wouldn't want me to have, but they nonetheless flatly refused to give it to me for no reason other than that if the pills I wanted caused more improvement than the anti-depressants, it would prove that I knew more than they did, and they simply could not tolerate that.  Rather than be proven wrong, they'd rather make me worse.
 
Whatever happened to "first, do no harm"?
 
 

No comments: